Clare Solicitor Admonished Over Unpaid Senior Counsel Fees
A Clare-based solicitor has been found guilty of professional misconduct by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal following a regulatory complaint concerning unpaid barrister fees. The disciplinary inquiry, finalised on 29 January 2026, examined an application brought by the Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority against Colum Doherty, principal of C.N. Doherty & Co. Solicitors in Ennis. The tribunal determined that the practitioner failed to discharge his professional obligations by not taking reasonable steps to ensure that fees properly owed to a senior counsel were recovered at the earliest opportunity.
Failure to Pursue Counsel's Outstanding Fees
The formal inquiry centred on allegations that Mr Doherty failed to use his best or reasonable endeavours to recover fees legitimately owed to John Gibbons SC. Under long-standing professional practice and statutory standards governing Irish legal practitioners, instructing solicitors bear an affirmative duty to actively pursue and resolve outlays and fees due to instructed counsel. The tribunal found that by neglecting to progress the recovery of these fees in a timely and diligent manner, Mr Doherty committed professional misconduct under the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015.
The issue of fee recovery between the two branches of the legal profession remains a sensitive and strictly regulated area within the Irish legal framework. While solicitors instruct barristers on behalf of lay clients, regulatory and professional conduct norms require solicitors to maintain proactive communication and diligently seek the discharge of counsel's legitimate costs. Where a solicitor fails to take reasonable measures to recover such remuneration, the disciplinary bodies have consistently treated the lapse as a breach of professional conduct rather than a simple commercial disagreement.
Background to the Disciplinary Application
The fees in dispute originated from protracted proceedings concerning an application brought before the previous regulatory body, the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal. The underlying matter related to proceedings entitled In the Matter of Michael A. O'Brien, a Solicitor of Michael A. O'Brien & Co., based at Castle Street, Carrick-on-Suir, County Tipperary, following an application brought by Pat Murphy under record number 4405/DT12/12. Senior Counsel John Gibbons had been engaged to provide specialist advocacy and advisory services during those historical disciplinary proceedings.
Despite the conclusion of the substantive legal work, the senior counsel's fees remained outstanding over an extended duration without adequate recovery efforts being mounted. The Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority subsequently intervened, investigating the circumstances surrounding the non-recovery of the professional fees before bringing formal disciplinary proceedings under Case 2025-LPDT38. The outcome underscores the statutory watchdog's readiness to pursue enforcement action when administrative neglect undermines the remuneration of court-appointed or retained counsel.
Sanctions Imposed Under the 2015 Act
Having recorded a finding of professional misconduct, the tribunal considered the appropriate sanctions under Section 82 of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015. Rather than escalating the matter to higher-tier penalties, the tribunal determined that an admonishment under Section 82(1)(b) was warranted. Crucially, the tribunal did not order a suspension, censure, or strike-off against Mr Doherty, allowing him to continue legal practice from his offices at Steeles Terrace on Lifford Road in Ennis.
In addition to the formal admonishment, financial remedies were directed to rectify the outstanding dispute. Under Section 82(1)(i), Mr Doherty was ordered to pay €5,000 plus VAT as part restitution directly to John Gibbons SC within 28 days of the inquiry hearing. The tribunal stipulated that this restitution payment must be transacted through Fieldfisher LLP, the legal firm representing the applicant regulatory authority. To cover the institutional costs of the inquiry, Mr Doherty was also ordered under Section 82(1)(j) to contribute €3,000 including VAT towards the Legal Services Regulatory Authority's expenses within 56 days.
The Evolving Regulatory Framework for Irish Practitioners
The ruling represents another significant exercise of statutory oversight by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, which was established to provide an independent, transparent mechanism for hearing complaints against both solicitors and barristers in Ireland. Prior to the full enactment of the 2015 reforms, complaints regarding solicitors were largely determined through the internal structures of the Law Society of Ireland. The modern regime places statutory authority firmly under an independent remit designed to protect public confidence and maintain integrity within the administration of justice.
For practitioners across Ireland, the decision serves as an important precedent regarding internal operational diligence. Failing to actively chase and settle fees due to third-party experts, barristers, or colleagues is not merely a civil bookkeeping matter, but can trigger rigorous regulatory scrutiny. By compelling partial restitution and cost contributions while issuing a formal admonishment, the tribunal highlighted that administrative complacency in professional fee management carries tangible financial and disciplinary consequences.
Free Claim Assessment
Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.
Start Free Assessment