Clare Solicitor Admonished Over Unpaid Senior Counsel Fees
An Ennis-based solicitor has been found guilty of professional misconduct by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal after failing to take appropriate steps to recover fees properly due to a Senior Counsel. Colum Doherty, principal of C.N. Doherty & Co. Solicitors located at Steeles Terrace, Lifford Road in Ennis, County Clare, was formally admonished and directed to pay both restitution and legal costs following an inquiry brought forward by the Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority.
The determination, issued under record number 2025-LPDT38, concluded that Mr Doherty failed to use his best or reasonable endeavours to recover fees properly owed to John Gibbons SC at the earliest possible opportunity. Under longstanding conventions within the Irish legal system, instructing solicitors bear distinct professional obligations regarding the recovery and discharge of fees incurred by instructed counsel. While fee arrangements frequently involve complex party-and-party recovery procedures following litigation, solicitors are expected to exercise due diligence to ensure that colleagues briefed on behalf of clients are not left unpaid due to administrative inaction.
Origins in Historical Disciplinary Proceedings
The controversy stemmed from historical professional disciplinary proceedings entitled In the Matter of Michael A. O'Brien, a Solicitor of Michael A. O'Brien & Co., Castle Street, Carrick-on-Suir, County Tipperary. That litigation arose from an application brought by Pat Murphy before the predecessor Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal under record number 4405/DT12/12. Senior Counsel John Gibbons had been retained in relation to those proceedings, but the recovery of his professional fees subsequently stalled, culminating in formal complaints to the regulatory body.
The relationship between instructing solicitors and the independent Bar of Ireland relies heavily on prompt commercial administration and mutual professional reliance. When an instructing solicitor fails to take reasonable steps to demand or enforce payment for counsel's work, the issue can cross the boundary from a standard commercial dispute into the realm of professional misconduct. In this instance, the Legal Services Regulatory Authority established that the ongoing omission to pursue the outstanding monies constituted a breach of core professional obligations.
Tribunal Sanctions and Financial Restitution
At the conclusion of its inquiry, the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal imposed several statutory orders against Mr Doherty pursuant to Section 82 of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015. Under Section 82(1)(b) of the Act, the tribunal directed that the practitioner be formally admonished. An admonishment represents an official censure placed upon a solicitor's professional record, noting substandard professional conduct while permitting the practitioner to continue in practice without suspension.
To remedy the outstanding financial default, the tribunal ordered Mr Doherty under Section 82(1)(i) to pay restitution of €5,000 plus VAT directly to John Gibbons SC. This payment was directed to be made within 28 days of the inquiry hearing date. The tribunal specified that the restitution must be routed through Fieldfisher LLP, the Dublin legal firm representing the Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority throughout the proceedings.
Mr Doherty was also penalised in respect of the statutory costs incurred in investigating and prosecuting the disciplinary complaint. Pursuant to Section 82(1)(j) of the 2015 Act, the tribunal ordered the Clare solicitor to contribute €3,000, inclusive of VAT, towards the regulatory authority's costs. This sum must be paid within 56 days of the inquiry hearing date, also through Fieldfisher LLP. No further restrictions or orders were imposed on his practising certificate.
Regulatory Framework and Inter-Professional Standards
The case underscores the broad remit of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority, which was established to provide independent oversight of both branches of the Irish legal profession. Prior to the full implementation of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015, disciplinary matters regarding solicitors were primarily overseen through internal bodies managed by the Law Society of Ireland. The modern statutory framework places complaints, disciplinary inquiries, and standards enforcement under an independent regime aimed at enhancing accountability and transparency across the sector.
The ruling serves as an important precedent regarding inter-professional financial responsibilities in Irish legal practice. Instructing solicitors are reminded that their administrative obligations extend beyond client communication and court filings. Failing to actively seek the recovery of fees legitimately owed to barristers briefed in complex litigation will continue to draw strict scrutiny and enforcement from the disciplinary authorities.
Free Claim Assessment
Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.
Start Free Assessment