26 reader checks this week

Cork Solicitor Censured Over Bank Undertaking Breach

| By Legal News Team | Updated
Cork Solicitor Censured Over Bank Undertaking Breach

A Cork-based solicitor has been formally censured by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal following an inquiry into a long-standing, unfulfilled financial undertaking. John Moylan, who practises under the firm Richard Moylan and Co Solicitors on Shortcastle Street in Mallow, County Cork, was found guilty of professional misconduct arising from a failure to honour commitments given to a commercial lender nearly eight years ago.

The finding was handed down following proceedings initiated by the Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority. Operating under record reference 2025/LPDT32, the tribunal determined that Mr Moylan had breached the high standards expected of the profession by failing to comply with an undertaking provided to Ulster Bank Ireland DAC in late 2018.

Breach of 2018 Commercial Undertaking

At the centre of the disciplinary hearing was a formal undertaking furnished by Mr Moylan to Ulster Bank Ireland DAC, dated 4 December 2018. The tribunal found that the practitioner failed to comply, in a timely manner or at all, with the terms set out in that document, whether in whole or in part. In Irish property and lending practice, professional undertakings represent binding promises to perform specific legal acts, such as stamping deeds, registering mortgages, or clearing previous encumbrances.

Following Ulster Bank’s subsequent departure from the Irish retail banking market and the large-scale transfer of its performing loan books, oversight of the affected security transitioned to Permanent TSB. As part of its determinations, the tribunal mandated specific steps to ensure the legal position of the underlying loan portfolio is finally regularised, shielding the financial institution and client title from continuing exposure.

Statutory Sanctions and Compliance Measures

Exercising its powers under the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015, the tribunal imposed a formal censure against Mr Moylan pursuant to section 82(1)(c) of the legislation. In addition to the public rebuke, the disciplinary panel ordered robust corrective mechanisms to guarantee that the underlying obligations are finally resolved without further delay.

Under section 82(1)(f) of the Act, a compliance order was directed requiring Mr Moylan to arrange full compliance with the 2018 undertaking. To maintain independent monitoring, the tribunal stipulated that the solicitor must furnish written status updates to Permanent TSB at least once every quarter of each calendar year. The tribunal established a clear compliance timetable, scheduling the next formal update to be delivered to the bank before the end of September 2026.

Costs Awarded to the Regulatory Authority

Beyond the censure and reporting mandates, the tribunal addressed the substantial costs incurred in bringing the disciplinary proceedings. Under section 82(1)(j) of the 2015 Act, Mr Moylan was ordered to discharge the legal costs sustained by the Legal Services Regulatory Authority in conducting the inquiry hearing. The tribunal capped these recoverable expenses at €15,000, inclusive of Value Added Tax.

Should the parties fail to reach an agreement regarding the final sum, the assessment will be referred to the Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators. Operating within the Courts Service framework, the Adjudicators carry statutory authority to independently evaluate disputed legal fees, ensuring billed amounts remain reasonable, necessary, and strictly proportionate to the scale of the disciplinary inquiry.

The Crucial Role of Undertakings in Irish Law

Solicitor undertakings sit at the bedrock of Irish conveyancing, residential property purchases, and secured commercial lending. Because financial institutions cannot independently verify every stage of property title creation in real time, lenders advance loan cheques and release original deeds relying entirely on a practitioner’s solemn promise to secure and register the bank’s charge promptly.

The superior courts in Ireland have consistently maintained that the system of property purchase and lending would collapse without absolute faith in solicitor undertakings. Where a practitioner neglects these duties, institutions and purchasers face clouded titles and unresolved equity issues. The strict supervisory approach adopted by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal highlights the state regulatory system’s determination to protect public and commercial confidence in Irish legal practice.

Free Claim Assessment

Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.

Start Free Assessment