Donegal Solicitor Censured Over Decade-Old Property Undertaking
A County Donegal solicitor has been formally censured by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal after being found guilty of professional misconduct arising from a conveyancing undertaking that went unfulfilled for more than a decade. The disciplinary determination relates to Jacqueline Sharkey, who practises with the firm O'Donnell and Sweeney in Dungloe, following a regulatory inquiry initiated by the Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority.
The tribunal heard that the matter stemmed from a property transaction completed in or around March 2013. In connection with that purchase, Ms Sharkey had furnished a formal undertaking dated 11 March 2013 to another legal practice, Sweeney McHugh Solicitors. The tribunal determined that she subsequently failed to arrange compliance with that commitment, either entirely or within an acceptable timeframe, leaving the underlying registration matters unresolved for years.
In addition to the breach of the undertaking itself, the tribunal upheld a second allegation concerning an ongoing failure of professional communication. It found that Ms Sharkey had failed to ensure appropriate engagement with Sweeney McHugh Solicitors in response to correspondence received following the completion of the transaction. This prolonged absence of adequate communication formed a central component of the misconduct findings under the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015.
The Role of Undertakings in Irish Conveyancing
Within Irish legal and property practice, solicitor undertakings are fundamental to the transfer of real estate. When residential or commercial property changes hands, lending institutions and purchasers' legal representatives routinely release funds and exchange deeds on the faith of an undertaking. These formal, legally binding commitments guarantee that a practitioner will complete crucial steps, such as clearing outstanding mortgages or lodging title documentation for registration.
Because the conveyancing system relies entirely on mutual professional trust, regulatory bodies treat the breach of an undertaking with significant gravity. Delays in completing registrations with Tailte Éireann—formerly the Property Registration Authority and Land Registry—can leave purchasers in legal limbo, complicate future mortgage applications, and compromise marketable title. Regulators have consistently emphasised that administrative backlogs or office pressures do not excuse open-ended delays on formal undertakings.
Sanctions and Mandated Professional Training
Delivering its decision on 8 January 2026 under record number 2025-LPDT57, the Disciplinary Tribunal imposed targeted statutory sanctions under Section 82 of the 2015 Act. Rather than recommending severe measures such as suspension or strike-off, the tribunal focused on corrective action, professional censure, and educational rehabilitation. The ruling did not include fines or requirements to contribute to the Law Society Compensation Fund.
Under Section 82(1)(c), the tribunal issued a formal censure against Ms Sharkey. To address the procedural weaknesses highlighted by the inquiry, the tribunal ordered her, pursuant to Section 82(1)(d), to complete two specific professional competence modules within seven months of the inquiry date. These courses, which must be completed in addition to standard annual Continuing Professional Development quotas, comprise the 'Applications - what can go wrong? Preparing Applications' webinar from the CPD Board and the 'Ethics and Professional Conduct Webinar' conducted by La Touche.
Under Section 82(1)(g), Ms Sharkey is also required to actively discharge the 11 March 2013 undertaking. The order mandates that she provide quarterly updates to the Legal Services Regulatory Authority every three months until the matter is fully rectified through completed title registration. Additionally, she was ordered under Section 82(1)(j) to pay a contribution of €5,000 toward the regulator's legal costs within six months of the hearing.
Regulatory Oversight and Professional Accountability
The outcome illustrates the statutory oversight exerted by the Legal Services Regulatory Authority, an independent watchdog tasked with supervising solicitors and barristers across the State. Established to modernise the regulation of legal services, the LSRA handles complaints regarding inadequate services, excessive fees, and professional misconduct, ensuring an independent avenue of redress outside traditional professional representative bodies.
For consumers and legal clients navigating property transactions in Ireland, the case demonstrates that regulatory mechanisms exist to address long-standing omissions and enforce accountability. By directing ongoing supervision until registration is formally achieved, the disciplinary authorities have reinforced that conveyancing promises cannot simply be allowed to lapse through the passage of time.
Free Claim Assessment
Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.
Start Free Assessment