Donegal Solicitor Censured Over 13-Year Conveyancing Delay
A County Donegal solicitor has been formally censured and directed to pay regulatory costs following findings of professional misconduct concerning a property undertaking that remained unresolved for nearly thirteen years. In a determination published under record number 2025-LPDT57, the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal ruled against Jacqueline Sharkey, who practises with the firm O\'Donnell and Sweeney Solicitors based in Dungloe.
The regulatory inquiry stemmed from an application brought by the Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority under the framework established by the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015. Following deliberations concluded on 8 January 2026, the Tribunal determined that the respondent solicitor had engaged in professional misconduct across two distinct allegations relating to a domestic property transaction completed in the spring of 2013.
Longstanding Failure to Honour Professional Promise
The core of the findings related to a formal undertaking provided on 11 March 2013 to another legal practice, Sweeney McHugh Solicitors. The Tribunal concluded that the respondent had failed to arrange compliance with the undertaking, either at all or within an adequate timeframe. Furthermore, the disciplinary body found that she failed to maintain appropriate professional engagement in response to correspondence issued by Sweeney McHugh Solicitors following the completion of the property purchase around March 2013.
In Irish conveyancing practice, professional undertakings represent the bedrock of residential and commercial transactions. Given the procedural timelines involved in lodging deeds, stamping documents with Revenue, and finalising title entries with Tailte Éireann (formerly the Property Registration Authority), property purchases routinely close on foot of formal undertakings given by one solicitor to another. These binding obligations guarantee that vital post-completion formalities, such as clearing prior mortgages or completing title registration, will be carried out diligently. When an undertaking remains unfulfilled for over a decade, it threatens the integrity of the land transfer framework and risks leaving purchasers and lenders in prolonged legal uncertainty.
Statutory Orders and CPD Sanctions
Having established the misconduct findings, the Tribunal made a series of statutory directions under Section 82 of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015. Pursuant to Section 82(1)(c), the Tribunal ordered that the respondent be formally censured. To address professional standards, an order was made under Section 82(1)(d) requiring participation in two specific professional competence courses within seven months of the inquiry date, over and above her mandatory annual Continuing Professional Development obligations.
These educational courses comprise the CPD Board webinar entitled \'Applications - what can go wrong? Preparing Applications\' alongside the \'Ethics and Professional Conduct Webinar\' provided by legal training body La Touche. To resolve the underlying transaction, an order under Section 82(1)(g) mandates full compliance with the original March 2013 undertaking. The solicitor must furnish regular progress reports to the LSRA every three months until the property registration is formally perfected.
In addition to these corrective measures, the Tribunal invoked Section 82(1)(j) to require a contribution of €5,000 towards the legal costs incurred by the Complaints Committee, payable within six months. The Tribunal did not issue an admonishment, nor did it recommend severe sanctions such as suspension or strike-off from the Roll of Solicitors, which would have required referral to the High Court. No orders were made for client restitution or payments from the Law Society Compensation Fund.
Regulatory Oversight Under the 2015 Framework
The outcome illustrates the ongoing enforcement powers exercised by the LSRA since assuming independent oversight of legal complaints in Ireland. Prior to the establishment of the independent regulatory structure, complaints regarding professional standards and solicitors\' undertakings were handled predominantly through internal Law Society committees. The modern disciplinary mechanism offers a public, transparent avenue for addressing grievances, ensuring solicitors remain accountable for inter-firm obligations and administrative duties.
While the Tribunal\'s notice did not detail the specific nature of the land registry requirements or the precise grounds for the historic delay, the strict requirement for quarterly reporting underlines the regulator\'s focus on bringing prolonged conveyancing matters to finality. The matter serves as a stark reminder across the Irish legal sector that standard conveyancing undertakings are strictly binding legal commitments that carry substantial disciplinary exposure if allowed to lapse into years of inaction.
Free Claim Assessment
Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.
Start Free Assessment