High Court Dismisses Everyday Finance Action Over Inordinate Delay
In a significant ruling clarifying the judiciary's increasingly strict stance on stalled debt litigation, the High Court has dismissed debt recovery proceedings brought by Everyday Finance Designated Activity Company for want of prosecution. The judgment, delivered by Mr Justice Paul Coffey, underscores the transformative impact of the Supreme Court's modernised framework governing excessive litigation delay, serving as a firm warning to institutional debt purchasers that prolonged inaction will no longer be tolerated in Irish courtrooms.
A Six-Year Litigation Standstill
The dispute in Everyday Finance DAC v Solan centred on liabilities arising from two loan facilities initially advanced to the borrower by Ulster Bank Ireland. Following widespread restructuring in the domestic retail banking sector and Ulster Bank's phased departure from the Irish market, the underlying debt was assigned along a chain of title that ultimately landed with Everyday Finance, trading as Link Financial. The fund initiated summary summons proceedings in the High Court in April 2019 seeking to recover the outstanding balance.
While the proceedings were served promptly in May 2019 and the defendant entered an appearance later that same month, the litigation ground to a sudden and protracted halt. The plaintiff took no further formal procedural steps to advance the claim towards a hearing or seek judgment. The standstill continued uninterrupted until November 2025, when the defendant issued a formal motion to dismiss the action for want of prosecution, marking an overall lapse of roughly six and a half years of procedural silence.
Accounting for the Covid Moratorium and Negotiations
In resisting the strike-out application, the loan servicer pointed to two principal periods that contributed to the extensive timeline. The first was an approximate six-month window during which the parties engaged in without-prejudice settlement discussions in an attempt to restructure or resolve the liability. The second was an estimated nine-month period during the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, throughout which financial institutions observed a non-statutory moratorium on debt collection enforcement at the express behest of the Central Bank of Ireland.
While the High Court acknowledged both mitigating factors and factored them out of the calculation, Mr Justice Coffey observed that this still left an unexplained deficit of procedural inactivity exceeding five full years. Even after granting full credit for legitimate pauses such as pandemic forbearance and bona fide negotiations, the residual delay comfortably placed the litigation within the most critical category of procedural default recognised under contemporary Irish jurisprudence.
Applying the Kirwan v Connors Precedent
For nearly three decades, Irish courts evaluated delay under the well-worn three-tier test established in Primor plc v Stokes Kennedy Crowley, which required establishing whether delay was inordinate, whether it was inexcusable, and where the balance of justice lay. However, Mr Justice Coffey grounded his analysis in the reformulated framework established by the Supreme Court in Kirwan v Connors. Authored by Chief Justice Donal O'Donnell, that benchmark decision fundamentally shifted the balance of justice, placing far greater constitutional weight on the mere passage of time and the public interest in efficient case management.
Under the Kirwan guidelines, where systemic delay crosses the five-year threshold without reasonable excuse, proceedings enter a distinct and rigorous category. At this juncture, the central inquiry is whether a pressing exigency of justice exists that necessitates permitting the claim to proceed to trial despite the default. During the hearing, Everyday Finance conceded that it was unable to point to any such pressing exigency, leaving the fund without the requisite justification to keep the case alive.
Implications for Stalled Debt Claims
Everyday Finance argued that because the claim was largely documentary and straightforward, the borrower suffered no concrete prejudice, as the core financial records remained intact. Mr Justice Coffey rejected this line of defence, clarifying that while the documentary nature of a debt and an absence of prejudice might save proceedings in lower categories of delay, they do not satisfy the higher threshold demanded once an action has languished for more than five years.
The ruling represents an important indicator for the Courts Service, debt acquisition funds, and borrowers navigating legacy mortgage and personal loan portfolios. Financial funds that acquire distressed loans have historically allowed summary proceedings to remain dormant while attempting informal recovery or awaiting market changes. The decision in Solan demonstrates that the High Court will strictly enforce constitutional standards of timely justice, and claims left unattended for years face outright strike-out, regardless of the underlying merits of the debt.
Free Claim Assessment
Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.
Start Free Assessment