26 reader checks this week

High Court Quashes WRC Private Hearing Order in State Case

| By Legal News Team | Updated
High Court Quashes WRC Private Hearing Order in State Case

In an important ruling addressing the boundary between transparency and confidentiality in employment disputes, the High Court has quashed an adjudication officer's direction that had ordered a series of interrelated claims before the Workplace Relations Commission to be conducted entirely in private. The decision in Adeyanju v Workplace Relations Commission and Another underscores the strict statutory standards that must be met before an employment tribunal can exclude the press and members of the public from statutory redress hearings.

The litigation originated from multiple workplace grievances and disputes pursued by an employee formerly engaged by the Chief State Solicitor's Office. These proceedings comprise both statutory complaints under employment protection legislation and broader industrial disputes referred under the Industrial Relations Act 1969. When the matters were scheduled before a Workplace Relations Commission adjudication officer, a blanket direction was issued ordering that all proceedings be held otherwise than in public, prompting the worker to seek judicial review in the High Court to restore public access.

The Statutory Presumption of Open Justice

At the core of the High Court's consideration was Section 41(13) of the Workplace Relations Act 2015, which provides that hearings under statutory employment enactments must be conducted in public as the default standard. This provision reflects constitutional guarantees of open justice, ensuring public oversight of administrative tribunals carrying out judicial or quasi-judicial functions. An adjudication officer possesses the statutory power to deviate from this principle only where satisfied that specific, identifiable 'special circumstances' exist to justify hearing a complaint behind closed doors.

The procedural position was complicated by the presence of parallel industrial relations matters. While Section 41 complaints carry a clear statutory default of open justice, disputes referred under Section 13 of the Industrial Relations Act 1969 are governed by an opposing statutory mandate. Under Section 13(8) of the 1969 Act, investigations into such collective or non-binding disputes are required to take place in private. Rather than untangling the distinct procedures, the original adjudication officer had directed that all interconnected matters proceed entirely in camera.

Judicial Review in Unopposed Claims

Notably, neither the Workplace Relations Commission nor the Chief State Solicitor's Office opposed the application to quash the private hearing order. However, the High Court observed that consent or non-opposition from respondents does not automatically entitle an applicant to judicial review relief. Citing the Supreme Court authority of Ballyboden Tidy Towns Group v An Bord Pleanála, the court reiterated that the burden remains on the applicant to establish that the High Court's supervisory jurisdiction is lawfully engaged before an order of certiorari can be granted.

Upon reviewing the record, the court concluded that the adjudication officer had committed a fatal legal error by failing to identify any individual 'special circumstances' that could justify displacing the public hearing default for the statutory complaints. The mere fact that the Section 41 claims were factually linked to Section 13 industrial relations claims was insufficient to extinguish the statutory mandate of open justice. An administrative tribunal cannot bypass constitutional and legislative transparency requirements merely for administrative convenience.

Strict Directives on Remittal

To remedy the defect, the High Court remitted the underlying disputes back to the Workplace Relations Commission for fresh consideration before a different adjudication officer. The court set out clear parameters for how the renewed proceedings must be structured. The two trade dispute investigations under Section 13 of the Industrial Relations Act 1969 must strictly be heard in private, preserving the confidential negotiation environment intended by industrial relations statutes.

Conversely, for any claim falling under Section 41 of the Workplace Relations Act 2015, public hearings remain the mandatory starting point. If any party seeks, or an adjudication officer proposes, to conduct any portion of those statutory hearings in private, the officer must articulate the precise special circumstances relied upon. Furthermore, the decision-maker must provide a reasoned explanation as to why those facts justify departing from open justice and explicitly examine whether less restrictive alternatives, such as partial anonymisation, could adequately protect sensitive interests.

Free Claim Assessment

Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.

Start Free Assessment