Two Kildare Solicitors Censured Over Accounts and Settlement Breaches
Two practising solicitors based in County Kildare have been censured and ordered to pay a combined €30,000 in penalties and costs following findings of professional misconduct across seven separate allegations. The determinations were delivered by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal against Andrew Coonan and Susanna Cawley, partners in the Naas firm Coonan Cawley, located at Wolfe Tone House in Naas Town Centre.
The proceedings, brought forward by the Law Society of Ireland under the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015, culminated in a formal finding of misconduct against both practitioners on 1 July 2025. While the disciplinary tribunal chose not to impose restrictions on their practising certificates or recommend suspension, the sanctions reflect substantial breaches of core statutory duties governing client account administration, transaction transparency, and the handling of litigation settlement funds.
Strict Accounting Protocols and Client Protection
At the centre of the tribunal's findings were multiple violations of the Solicitors Accounts Regulations 2014, statutory instruments designed to ensure that client assets remain completely insulated from practice capital. The tribunal determined that both practitioners breached Regulation 7(1) by withdrawing funds when their accounts were not in funds, alongside breaches of Regulation 7(2) by permitting client ledger accounts to slip into debit balance. In Irish legal practice, running a deficit on a client ledger is regarded as a severe governance lapse because client monies must at all times be held on trust without exposure to shortfall.
Further accounting breaches identified under the determination involved improper withdrawals for legal fees. The tribunal found breaches of Regulation 9(4), concerning the extraction of money for professional costs when the firm was not entitled to do so, including instances where funds were drawn from stakeholder funds. In addition, the partners were found in breach of Regulation 12(3) for withdrawing professional fees that were not properly payable to the practice, and Regulation 13 for failing to retain proper supporting documentation to verify and vouch for cash payments involving clients.
Unauthorised Fee Deductions from Settlement Sums
Of particular interest to claimants and litigants navigating the Irish courts is the tribunal's finding that both practitioners breached section 68(3) of the Solicitors (Amendment) Act 1994. Under this cornerstone statute, which was introduced to bring transparency to legal charges, solicitors are strictly prohibited from deducting professional fees and outlays directly from a client's settlement cheque or court-awarded damages without prior, explicit written authorisation from the client.
In contentious litigation—ranging from disputes before the Workplace Relations Commission to personal injury matters managed through the Injuries Resolution Board and the High Court—monies recovered are the property of the client. The statutory requirement for unambiguous written approval prevents practitioners from unilaterally resolving fee disputes or satisfying invoices through client awards. By failing to secure the requisite written consent before executing fee deductions, the practitioners compromised a critical consumer protection safeguard.
Conveyancing Conflicts and Tribunal Penalties
The tribunal also upheld allegations under the Solicitors (Conveyancing Conflict of Interest) Regulations 2012. Both solicitors were found guilty of misconduct for acting on behalf of both parties in a property conveyance where the transfer price was below market value. The Law Society's regulations strictly curtail dual representation in property dealings, recognising that acting for both vendor and purchaser creates an inherent conflict of loyalty, particularly when property is changing hands beneath genuine open-market valuations.
In formulating the final orders, the tribunal applied identical sanctions to each respondent under the statutory framework of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015. Under section 82(1)(c), Andrew Coonan and Susanna Cawley were each formally censured. Pursuant to section 82(1)(l), each practitioner must contribute €10,000 to the Law Society of Ireland Compensation Fund—a statutory fund maintained to indemnify members of the public against losses caused by dishonest or defaulting solicitors. Furthermore, under section 82(1)(j), both were directed to pay €5,000 towards the Law Society's legal costs.
The published determination did not disclose the precise financial values associated with the accounts breaches or conveyancing transactions, nor did it specify formal deadlines for payment. The tribunal declined to impose remedial measures such as supervised training, restitution orders, or practice management conditions, allowing both solicitors to maintain their active legal practices in Naas subject to the published censures and financial sanctions.
Free Claim Assessment
Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.
Start Free Assessment