Mayo Solicitor Admonished Over Costs Adjudication Delays
Mayo solicitor Catherine McDarby has been admonished and ordered to return more than €10,000 in client funds following a finding of professional misconduct by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. The disciplinary outcome, published under record number 2025-LPDT12, stems from an inquiry into the solicitor's handling of disputed legal fees and an ongoing failure to set costs down for independent adjudication. McDarby, who practises at McDarby & Co. on Glebe Street in Ballinrobe, County Mayo, was the subject of an investigation brought forward by the Complaints Committee of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority following a complaint from a former client.
On 22 September 2025, the Tribunal formally determined that McDarby was guilty of professional misconduct under the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015. Specifically, the panel found that she had failed, either entirely or within an acceptable timeframe, to refer contested legal costs for formal assessment. In disputes concerning legal remuneration, practitioners who retain money in a client account while fees are contested are required to progress the matter promptly to avoid causing unfair financial prejudice to the client.
Sanctions and Orders for Fee Waivers
Following the misconduct finding, the Tribunal made a comprehensive series of remedial orders pursuant to Section 82(1) of the Act. In addition to receiving an admonishment, McDarby was ordered to waive all of her firm's own professional fees and outlay connected with the matter. This statutory waiver effectively deprives the practice of remuneration for its own legal services, excluding only a contested figure of €16,328.25 that represents disputed counsel's fees.
The Tribunal directed the solicitor to release €10,887.19 currently held in her client account and pay it directly to the complainant within 14 days of the inquiry. Regarding the outstanding €16,328.25 in counsel's fees, McDarby has been given a period of 28 days to resolve the disagreement with the client. If the parties fail to reach an agreement within this timeframe, the solicitor must arrange for the formal adjudication of those fees entirely at her own personal expense.
Further directions require the transfer of all relevant case documentation to the complainant or their nominated legal representative within 28 days. To address professional practice deficiencies, McDarby must also undertake the continuing professional development course 'Legal Fees and Billing' within six months, lodging proof of completion one month thereafter. She was also instructed to pay €5,000 towards the legal costs incurred by the Complaints Committee within six months. The Tribunal did not issue a censure, order a suspension, recommend a strike-off, or mandate a contribution to the Compensation Fund.
The Role of the Legal Costs Adjudicator
This case underscores a fundamental protection available to legal clients across Ireland. Formerly administered through the Courts Service under the Taxing Master system, the dispute resolution framework was modernised by the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015, which established the Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators. When a client questions the fairness, proportionality, or calculation of a bill presented by a solicitor or barrister, they maintain a statutory entitlement to have the account reviewed independently by a Legal Costs Adjudicator.
The statutory regime imposes explicit obligations upon practitioners, including the initial provision of Section 150 cost notices outlining estimated fees and outlay. When a client challenges a final bill, solicitors cannot indefinitely retain client money without initiating the adjudication process. Failing to submit disputed accounts to the adjudicator denies clients access to their own funds and frustrates the statutory resolution mechanism, turning an ordinary billing grievance into a regulatory disciplinary issue.
Regulatory Oversight Under the 2015 Act
The outcome highlights the active enforcement remit of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority, the independent statutory body tasked with overseeing both solicitors and barristers in Ireland. Unlike the former regulatory structures governed solely by the Law Society of Ireland, the current framework allows independent tribunals to hold practitioners accountable for procedural delays and client account irregularities. By issuing targeted financial penalties and compulsory training orders, the Tribunal seeks to reinforce transparency and ensure that practitioners adhere strictly to professional billing standards.
Free Claim Assessment
Find out if you have a valid claim — free, no obligation.
Start Free Assessment